Research Integrity and Peer Review
Scope & Guideline
Exploring the foundations of trust in academic publishing.
Introduction
Aims and Scopes
- Research Integrity:
The journal emphasizes the importance of ethical conduct in research, exploring themes like misconduct, plagiarism, and the role of institutions in upholding integrity. - Peer Review Practices:
A core focus is on peer review methodologies, examining the effectiveness, biases, and innovations in peer review, including the transition from single-blind to double-blind systems. - Diversity and Inclusion:
The journal addresses issues of equality, diversity, and inclusion in research and publishing, reflecting on how these factors impact funding, representation, and authorship. - Reporting Standards:
Promoting high-quality reporting practices through guidelines and checklists, the journal seeks to improve the completeness and transparency of research publications. - Impact of Funding on Research:
The journal investigates the influence of industry funding on research outcomes and publication practices, highlighting transparency and potential biases. - Open Science Initiatives:
There is a growing emphasis on the movement towards open science, encouraging practices that enhance accessibility and reproducibility in research.
Trending and Emerging
- Impact of COVID-19 on Research Practices:
Recent papers highlight the experiences and perceptions surrounding research during the COVID-19 pandemic, particularly in vaccine trials, reflecting the urgency and relevance of real-time research integrity. - Use of Technology in Peer Review:
There is a notable increase in discussions about the role of technology, including AI and large language models like ChatGPT, in transforming peer review processes and addressing reviewer fatigue. - Mentorship and Training in Peer Review:
Emerging themes include structured training programs for peer reviewers, indicating a shift towards enhancing the skills and capabilities of individuals involved in the peer review process. - Systemic Inequities in Research Funding:
The journal is increasingly addressing systemic issues related to gender disparities and equity in research funding, reflecting a growing awareness of inclusivity in academic publishing. - Transparency and Open Science:
New discussions emphasize the importance of transparency in research practices and open science initiatives, highlighting the movement towards more accessible and reproducible research.
Declining or Waning
- Traditional Views on Authorship:
The exploration of authorship issues, while still relevant, has seen a decrease in focus compared to the broader discussions on equity and representation in research. - Methodological Rigor in Peer Review:
Although methodological discussions are important, there appears to be a shift away from traditional peer review methodologies towards more innovative approaches that prioritize transparency and inclusivity. - General Research Misconduct Studies:
Broad studies on research misconduct are becoming less frequent as the journal shifts towards more specific case studies and practical recommendations for improvement.
Similar Journals
LEARNED PUBLISHING
Connecting Academia through Rigorous Peer ReviewLEARNED PUBLISHING, published by Wiley, stands as a premier journal in the fields of Communication and Library and Information Sciences, boasting a notable impact in the scholarly community with its prestigious Q1 rankings in both categories. Established in 1996 and covering an extensive range of topics until 2024, this journal serves as a vital platform for academics and professionals, fostering knowledge and innovation in the realm of publishing practices and scholarly communication. With a strong emphasis on contemporary issues in publishing, dissemination of research, and the evolving landscape of information sciences, LEARNED PUBLISHING is essential reading for anyone engaged in these dynamic fields. Although it does not currently offer open access options, its rigorous peer-review process ensures that the research published is of the highest quality, thereby supporting the growth of knowledge in the global academic community.
R Journal
Empowering Researchers with Rigorous InsightsR Journal, published by the R Foundation for Statistical Computing, is a premier academic journal dedicated to advancing the fields of numerical analysis and statistical methodologies. With an ISSN of 2073-4859, the journal has established itself as a significant platform for high-quality research since its inception in 2009. It operates under a Q2 category ranking in respective fields, including Statistics and Probability, among others, highlighting its influence and relevance in the academic community. Researchers are encouraged to contribute their findings, as the journal appeals broadly to statisticians, mathematicians, and data scientists alike. Although not an open-access journal, its commitment to rigorous peer review ensures that published works maintain high standards of scientific integrity. The R Journal's vision is to foster innovative approaches within statistical computing, making it an invaluable resource for those seeking to deepen their understanding or stay abreast of developments in the discipline.
Journal of Peer Learning
Advancing Knowledge through Collaborative Learning ResearchWelcome to the Journal of Peer Learning, an esteemed publication dedicated to advancing the field of education through innovative research focused on peer-assisted learning methodologies. Published by the University of Wollongong, Australia, this journal provides a platform for educators, researchers, and practitioners to disseminate their findings and cultivate a deeper understanding of peer learning across diverse educational contexts. With an ISSN of 2200-2359, this journal caters to a broad audience, despite its current categorization in the Q4 quartile of educational publications and a Scopus ranking of 1139 out of 1543 in the Social Sciences Education category. The Journal of Peer Learning does not operate under an open access model, but it remains a vital resource for those interested in collaborative learning strategies, peer engagement techniques, and best practices in educational settings. By enhancing the discourse surrounding peer learning, this journal aims to empower educators to implement evidence-based practices and contribute to the ongoing development of effective teaching and learning environments.
Journal of History-NCCU
Engaging with History: Where Narratives Meet MethodologiesThe Journal of History-NCCU is a prestigious academic publication produced by the Department of History at National Chengchi University in Taipei, Taiwan. With the ISSN 0301-9667, this journal serves as a vital platform for scholars and researchers dedicated to the exploration of historical narratives, methodologies, and interpretations, enriching the global discourse in the field of history. The journal emphasizes interdisciplinary approaches, welcoming contributions that intersect with cultural studies, sociology, and political science, thereby appealing to a broad audience of historians, professionals, and students alike. Although it does not currently offer Open Access options, the Journal of History-NCCU maintains a commitment to academic excellence, ensuring that its articles undergo thorough peer review to uphold rigorous scholarly standards. This journal is crucial for those seeking to deepen their understanding of historical contexts and engage with contemporary historiographical debates, positioning itself as an essential resource for advancing historical scholarship.
Current Research in Physiology
Uncovering New Dimensions in Physiology ResearchCurrent Research in Physiology is an esteemed academic journal published by Elsevier, aimed at advancing the field of physiology through high-quality research contributions. Since its inception in 2019, the journal has provided a platform for innovative studies and reviews, addressing both fundamental and applied aspects of physiology across various biological systems. With its ISSN 2665-9441, it operates under a non-open access model, ensuring rigorous peer review while also fostering a broad readership. The journal has been classified in the Q3 category for both Physiology and Medical Physiology as of 2023, reflecting its growing influence and relevance, as evidenced by its Scopus rankings within the respective fields. Designed for researchers, clinicians, and students alike, Current Research in Physiology is committed to disseminating cutting-edge research that informs both academic inquiry and clinical practice, paving the way for future advancements in physiological science.
Contabilidade Gestao e Governanca
Championing Open Access to Transformative ResearchContabilidade Gestao e Governanca is an esteemed open-access journal published by the Universidade de Brasília, focusing on the dynamic fields of accounting, management, and governance. Since its inception in 1998, this journal has committed itself to fostering scholarly communication and research dissemination within the realm of business administration. With an ISSN of 1984-3925, it offers valuable insights and innovative research findings to academics, practitioners, and students alike. The journal emphasizes rigorous peer review and strives to enhance the understanding of accounting practices and governance frameworks, making it a vital resource for those seeking to advance their knowledge in these critical areas. The journal's dedication to open access ensures that its high-quality content is readily available to a global audience, promoting knowledge equity and collaboration in the field.
PeerJ
Fostering collaboration in Agricultural and Biological Sciences.PeerJ, with an ISSN of 2167-8359 and E-ISSN of 2167-8359, is a prominent open-access journal published by PEERJ INC since 2013. Based in the United States, PeerJ is dedicated to advancing knowledge across various disciplines, with a notable focus on Agricultural and Biological Sciences, Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology, Medicine, and Neuroscience. PeerJ has quickly established itself in the academic community, achieving impressive rankings such as Q1 in Agricultural and Biological Sciences and Q2 in both Biochemistry and Medicine in 2023. With its robust open-access model, PeerJ ensures widespread accessibility of cutting-edge research, facilitating collaboration and dissemination of findings that push the boundaries of scientific inquiry. The journal's impact and reach continue to grow, making it an essential resource for researchers, professionals, and students alike who are keen on contributing to and learning from cutting-edge scientific discourse.
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
Defining Standards of Integrity in Science and EngineeringSCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS is a prestigious journal published by Springer, focusing on the intersection of ethics in scientific and engineering practices. With ISSN 1353-3452 and E-ISSN 1471-5546, this journal has been a critical platform for the dissemination of research from 1995 and continues to thrive as it approaches its convergence in 2024. The journal commands a significant reputation in its field, boasting Q1 rankings across multiple categories, including Health Policy, Health (Social Science), Issues, Ethics and Legal Aspects, and Management of Technology and Innovation in the 2023 category quartiles. Researchers and professionals will find it indispensable, as it ranks impressively in various Scopus metrics, particularly in Nursing and Health Policy, where it consistently places in the top percentiles. While the journal is not open access, its robust contribution to ongoing debates in ethics surrounding science and engineering makes it an essential read for scholars and practitioners seeking to navigate the complex moral landscapes of their fields.
Sport History Review
Bridging Disciplines to Understand Sports' Historical ImpactSport History Review, published by Human Kinetics, is a well-regarded, peer-reviewed journal dedicated to the exploration and analysis of sport's historical contexts and cultural influences. With a focus on interdisciplinary research, this journal serves as an essential resource for historians, scholars, and students interested in understanding the evolution of sports and its impact on society from various perspectives. The 2023 Scopus rankings place the journal in the Q2 category within History, indicating its significant scholarly influence, while also revealing its relevance within the fields of Physical Therapy and Sports Science. Despite its non-open access status, Sport History Review maintains a high standard of academic integrity and boasts a diverse array of articles that critically engage with themes ranging from historical sport practices to contemporary issues affecting athletic culture. With an established history of publication since 1999, the journal continues to enrich the academic landscape by providing a platform for innovative research, fostering dialogue, and advancing knowledge in sports history.
eLife
Connecting Ideas, Cultivating CollaborationeLife is a premier open-access journal that stands at the forefront of biological and medical research, published by eLIFE SCIENCES PUBL LTD in the United Kingdom. Since its inception in 2012, the journal has made significant strides in disseminating high-quality research across various key disciplines, including Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology, Immunology and Microbiology, and Neuroscience, maintaining a prestigious Q1 quartile ranking in all these fields as of 2023. With an impressive Scopus ranking placing it among the top-tier journals—12th in General Neuroscience, 24th in General Biochemistry, and 8th in General Immunology—eLife is recognized for its impact and influence in shaping research narratives. As an open-access journal, eLife facilitates global access to groundbreaking scientific discoveries, fostering collaboration and innovation among researchers, professionals, and students alike. With a commitment to rigorous peer review and publication excellence, eLife is not just a journal; it is a vital platform contributing to the advancement of life sciences.